Gonzalo Segares' 'Phantom Assist': You be the judge
by Tweed Thornton on Sep 2, 2011 6:01 AM CDT
in Fire Roster News & Analysis
Email
Print
In doing research for a story on Chicago Fire goals this season, I came across a couple of irregularities on the assist credits for some tallies. The initial press release after a game might have done something like given a second assist credit to Marco Pappa on Cory Gibbs' header vs. San Jose when he really didn't do that much to set up Baggio Husidic's ball into the box. In that same game, Cristian Nazarit was originally credited with an assist on the infamous 7/10 split where the ball hit both posts before Dominic Oduro slammed the ball in the net. Obviously Nazarit did not plan to get the ball to Oduro by having a shot hit the defender, have the ball deflect to hit the post, have the ball draw Jon Busch over to the wrong side, hit the other post, and then have Oduro be right there for the put-in. At least if Nazarit has that kind of aim, he is really wasting some talent. Just when I thought all these little things were ironed out, I came across the fact that Gonzalo Segares is being credited with 3 assists this year. More on why this is a curious case after the break.
Now the three assists represent a career season high for the 7-year MLS defender. His modest increase in offensive output reflects the role that interim head coach Frank Klopas has given him in pushing up more in the Fire attack. I remembered Segares getting the ball to Oduro in Philadelphia. I remembered his ground cross getting blocked and then sent in again to Oduro against Toronto. I could not think of what the other assist was... apparently they are giving it to him on Marco Pappa's dribbling showcase against Sporting KC at the home opener.
To me, that looks like an unassisted goal to by Pappa. That is how the original press release had it. That is even how the game recap on MLSSoccer.com still has it. In Gonzalo Segares' game log and the team's stats page, it lives on. What do you think? I think Marco Pappa does all the work to create the goal himself.
2 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Yeah, just because one player touched the ball before another player scores doesn’t necessarily warrant an assist.
Although, this leads to another interesting question: at what point does an assist no longer become an assist? IMO, if the goal scorer has 3 or more touches (including the actual shot), then it should be considered unassisted. The point of recognizing an assist is to recognize that one person’s effort essentially created the goal scoring opportunity for the goal scorer. I feel that if the goal scorer has to touch the ball more than twice, then he’s creating the opportunity.
Yeah, Segares does little to nothing to set that shot up for Pappa.
I think the ‘three touch’ rule makes a lot of sense. It is a skill to find a player in a dangerous position or even create a dangerous position with a simple pass but the danger was all created by Pappa here
Hot Time In Old Town SB Nation's blog for Chicago Fire, Soccer, & Chicago History
by Tweed Thornton on Sep 2, 2011 9:52 PM CDT via iPhone app up reply actions
Comments For This Post Are Closed
Secondary Sidebar
User Tools
Related FanPosts on Hot Time In Old Town
Related FanShots on Hot Time In Old Town
FanPosts
Community blog posts and discussion.
