Fireside Chat: In Which We Consider Columbus' Misfortunes

Greg Bartram-USA TODAY Sports

Missing three-quarters of their backline because of the World Cup, the Crew hope to ride Higuain's genius over the surging Men in Red; a chat with Massive Report

It's that time again - there are questions, and answers, and it's all about the match upcoming! This time, Patrick Murphy of Massive Report joins us with a look toward Saturday's showdown in Cowtown.

We ask, they answer

HT: Federico Higuain - Man or Super-Man? Discuss.
MR: Haha great question. In this league, I would say somewhere in between, leaning towards Super-Man. The Thierry Henry's and Robbie Keane's of MLS are the Super-Mans and Higuain is not quite there but he's in the next tier. Just last week, he reminded Crew fans of how good he is, chipping Donovan Ricketts from well outside the box with Ricketts not far off his line (if you haven't seen the goal, you should).
The forward is constantly moving and can be a goal scorer or a setup man. The fans in Columbus are getting spoiled, basically going from Guillermo Barros Schelotto to Federico. He may not have the name recognition of some of the players in this league but he certainly should be mentioned with them.
HT: Columbus has seemed to find their possession game, so successful in the early season, blunted in recent weeks. Has something changed? Is it just the breaks? How is the mood around the team right now?
MR: The possession numbers have actually stayed pretty consistent. The Black and Gold have been over 50% in every game this season. The issue, up until last week, was scoring goals. Early in the year the ball movement was resulting in goals, but recently no one has been able to find the net. After a three goal explosion last week against the Portland Timbers, it will be interesting to see if they can carry the goals over to this week.
In terms of the mood, I actually talked to several of the players about that this week. They were disappointed they didn't get the full three points last week, but encouraged with some of the play. They say the mood is still good because they know the results will come. They're playing the way they want to and the team believes in the system. Despite a lack of results, the soccer has usually been entertaining to watch.
HT: How is Michael Parkhurst's absence likely to affect the Crew's defense?
MR: It's not just Parkhust that is gone from the back line. His center back partner Giancarlo Gonzalez and left back Waylon Fracis are both with Costa Rica after starting every game before they left. The defense has been good for the Crew, allowing just over a goal a game until last week's late-game debacle in Portland and these three have been a big part of it. Parkhurst is rarely out of position defensively and Gonzalez has made some big time tackles early this season. Francis is a work horse getting up and down the flanks, which is crucial in Berhalter's system.
Last week, Berhalter started Tyson Wahl in the center of the defense with Gonzalez (who didn't leave until Sunday) and second-year player Chad Barson at left back. Neither had played much this season and that could have played a part in the late game collapse. I would imagine you would see more of the same this week with either Eric Gehrig or Kevan George, who was called up from his loan to the Crew's affiliate last week, partner Wahl. Another week of training should help the unit, but it wouldn't surprise me to see cracks in the armor.
Injuries: It sounded like a pretty healthy group today at practice. Rookie Matt Wiet is on the disabled list, but other than that everyone is expected to be available.
Predicted starting XI (4-4-1-1): Steve Clark; Josh Williams-Eric Gehrig-Tyson Wahl-Chad Barson; Hector Jimenez-Tony Tchani-Wil Trapp-Justin Meram; Federico Higuain; Jairo Arrieta.
Prediction: I'll go 2-1 Crew.

They ask, we answer

MR: After no wins in the first eight games, the Fire have now taken the full three points in their last two matches. Has their been a noticeable difference in the play or did things just finally start going Chicago's way?
HT: It's a little bit of both. The Fire clearly haven't had many problems going forward - they're averaging just a shade under two goals a game. Almost invariably, when Chicago have dropped points, it's been down to defensive failures - particularly in set-piece situations. Of the 19 goals the Fire have surrendered, something like 13 have come from dead balls. When the defense doesn't present goals like a bouquet of flowers to the opposition, Chicago are very hard to beat. That 'if' is a big 'if.'
MR: Mike Magee is the name most fans recognize, but rookie Harry Shipp and journey man Quincy Amarikwa both have had an impact for the Fire this season. Give Crew fans who may not have seen many Chicago games this year some background on these two and anyone else they might want to keep an eye on Saturday
HT: Harry Shipp is everything you've heard and then some, but the first thing you might notice is what he's not - he's not tall, he's not fast. He's not given to step-overs. But his first touch is among the best in the league; his vision and use of space make everyone around him a threat. In fact, if I had to compare him to another player in the league, it would be the Crew's own Federico Higuain. Like Higuain, he's the mind at the center of the motion.
Quincy Amarikwa's 2014 has been a feel-good story. Amarikwa seems undersized to play the target-man role, but tremendous upper-body strength and sense of leverage allow him to battle physical centerbacks. He's explosive, works hard for the team, and does a hilarious web series devoted to MLS fantasy and peppered with oddball challenges.
In terms of pure X-factor impact, it's doubtful we'll see much from Grant Ward on Saturday, but he's someone who will be playing a lot very soon. The 19-year-old flank defender, acquired on loan from Tottenham, was a revelation in preseason until a broken fifth metatarsal sidelined him for a couple of months. He's close enough now that making the gameday 18 on Saturday is a possilbility.
MR: Sean Johnson is a name that get mentioned with the U.S. squad quite a bit. He has made 110 appearances for Chicago before his 25th birthday, so he must be doing something right. Obviously he did not make this year's World Cup roster, but is he a legit option for the future? What makes him special in the Toyota Park net?
HT: Rangy, strong, and surprisingly quick, Johnson is a classic American shot-stopping keeper - witness his left-hand save on Thierry Henry that preserved the Fire's first win of the season. We've watched Sean progress from a nervous guy who flapped at crosses into an aggressive leader who demands accountability. His positioning, footwork and decision-making have improved to the point that he no longer has to bail himself out with highlight-reel saves as often, which is encouraging in a keeper who's only 25
Will Sean ever be the USA No. 1? He's at least in the conversation, which is something. Thing is, there's just one No. 1 at a time, he's behind Brad Guzan in the pecking order, and the USA has a passel of freak athletes at the position it is hoping to groom - the explosive but catlike Bill Hamid, for one. We shall see.
Injury update: Until today, we thought the roster was almost completely healthy. Bakary Soumare has suffered from, variously, migraines or soft-tissue injuries since being benched; his trouble is now said to be a calf difficulty, and his status for Saturday is unclear. Patrick Nyarko is fighting his usual assortment of knocks from being fouled relentlessly. Lovel Palmer hasn't practiced due to kidney stones, and apparently Mike Magee is 'battling calf tightness and soreness.' What these revelations mean for the starting XI is uncertain.
Projected starting XI (4-4-2): Sean Johnson; Gonzalo Segares, Patrick Ianni, Jhon Kennedy Hurtado, Lovel Palmer; Harry Shipp, Benji Joya, Jeff Larentowicz (c), Patrick Nyarko; Mike Magee, Quincy Amarikwa.
Prediction: Columbus 1-3 Chicago.
Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Hot Time In Old Town

You must be a member of Hot Time In Old Town to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Hot Time In Old Town. You should read them.

Join Hot Time In Old Town

You must be a member of Hot Time In Old Town to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Hot Time In Old Town. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.